Welcoming a new addition to your family often prompts moms to consider purchasing a breast pump, whether for medical reasons, returning to work, or personal preference. With several options on the market, finding the right one can be daunting. That’s why I have written this review to help you choose one based on your needs and budget. While I haven’t personally used an electric breast pump, my insights stem from comprehensive research and conversations with fellow moms.
Below are some points to consider before buying an electric breast pump:
- Pump Type: Determine if you need a manual, single electric, or double electric pump based on your pumping frequency and lifestyle.
- Portability: Consider whether you need a portable pump for on-the-go use, and if so, opt for a compact and lightweight design with a convenient carrying case.
- Power Source: Decide between battery-operated or electric based on your access to power sources and preference for flexibility
- Hygiene and Maintenance: If you are a busy mom you may want to consider pumps with easy-to-clean parts and dishwasher-safe components.
- Noise Level: Consider the noise level of the pump, especially if you plan to pump in shared spaces or during quiet times, and opt for a quieter model if possible.
Our Top Electric Breast Pumps:
- Best Overall Breast Pump: Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump.
- Also Great: Spectra S2 Plus Electric Breast Pump.
- Best Discreet Breast Pump: Elvie Electric Single Wearable Breast Pump with an app and the Elvie Electric Double Wearable Breast Pump with an app.
- Best Wearable Breast Pump: Elvie Stride Breast Pump.
- Best Lightweight Breast Pump: Momcozy M5 Wearable Breast Pump
I have also reviewed manual breast pumps for those interested. Click the link to learn more Best Manual Breast Pumps & Milk Collectors for 2024: Review by moms.
Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump Review
Best Overall Breast Pump
Welcome to the Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump Review. This pump is a hospital-grade pump and it stands out as a favored option among breastfeeding mothers due to its effectiveness, ergonomic design, and mobility features. Offering adjustable suction levels and a quiet motor, it enables discreet and comfortable milk expression. Its rechargeable battery facilitates convenient use wherever needed, be it at home, work, or during travels. Employing a closed system, it ensures hygiene and prevents contamination, addressing the concerns of mothers regarding their baby’s well-being.
The S1’s expression mode provides five speed settings, ranging from 38 to 54 cycles per minute, and 12 strength settings, with a maximum strength of 320mmHg. It has a back-flow protector which safeguards against mold growth and motor unit contamination, ensuring the purity of expressed breast milk. The Spectra S1 Pump comes equipped with a built-in light, making night time pumping convenient. Lastly, the pump is quiet which will allow you to pump anytime and anywhere.
Product Information
| Brand: | Spectra |
| ltem: | S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump |
| Material: | Silicone & Plastic |
| Color: | Blue & white |
| Product Dimensions: | 23 x 22 x 20cm |
| Item Weight: | 1.5 kg / 3.3 pounds |
| Operational Mode: | Electric |
| Special Feature: | Portable & rechargeable |
| Is it Dishwasher Safe? | The pump parts are dishwasher safe. |
| Best Place to Buy: | Buy on Amazon |
Spectra S1 Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Backflow protection: Backflow protection is a feature that is designed to prevent breast milk from coming into contact with harmful bacteria.
- Built-in light: The device has a built-in light, allowing moms to pump at any hour.
- Great suction: Several users have reported that they were effectively able to pump milk compared to other brands.
- Adjustable suction levels: The pump allows mothers to customize suction levels, enabling them to find the most comfortable and effective setting.
- Quiet operation: The Spectra S1 operates quietly, making it especially convenient for use while on the go due to its rechargeable battery.
Cons:
- Battery life: The Spectra S1 Plus has a battery life of 3 hours, which may be shorter than other brands.
- Size: Compared to other brands, the Spectra S1 model is bulkier, which some users may find inconvenient for portability.
Spectra S2 Plus Electric Breast Pump Review
Also a Great Electric Breast Pump
Welcome to the Spectra S2 Plus Double Electric Breast Pump Review. It is also a popular electric breast pump known for its efficiency and comfort. With customizable settings and hospital-grade performance, it’s designed to mimic a baby’s natural nursing pattern, making it a top choice for breastfeeding mothers seeking convenience and effectiveness in expressing milk. The Spectra S2 has the same features as the S1 except it does not come with a built-in battery.
Product Information
| Brand: | Spectra |
| Item: | S2 Plus Electric Breast Pump |
| Material: | Silicone & Plastic |
| Color: | Pink & white |
| Product Dimensions: | 7.9″L x 7.9″W x 6.7″H |
| Item Weight: | 1.5 kg / 3.3 pounds |
| Operation Mode: | Electric |
| Special Feature: | Portable |
| Is it Dishwasher Safe? | The pump parts are dishwasher safe. |
| Best Place to Buy: | Buy on Amazon |
Spectra S2 Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Backflow protection: Backflow protection is a feature designed to prevent breast milk from coming into contact with harmful bacteria.
- Built-in light: The device has a built in light, allowing moms to pump at any hour.
- Great suction: Several users have reported that they were effectively able to pump milk compared to other brands.
- Quiet operation: Like the Spectra S1, it operates quietly.
Cons:
- Power Source: It needs to be plugged into a power source to operate.
- Size: Compared to other brands, the Spectra S2 model is bulkier.
Last Thoughts!
The Spectra S1 and S2 Plus are popular electric breast pumps among nursing mothers, many of whom consider them a worthwhile investment due to their reliability and strong performance. These models are particularly praised for their quiet operation, night light feature, and comfortable pumping experience.The S1 is often the more favored option because of its rechargeable battery, offering the flexibility needed for pumping at work or on the go. In my opinion, the Spectra S1 particularly stands out for those parents who need to pump frequently and value the convenience of being able to pump whenever they need to. Its portability and ease of use make the extra expense worth it.
Elvie Electric Single & Double Wearable Breast Pump Review
Best Discreet Electric Breast Pumps
Elvie Single Electric Breast Pump
Welcome to the Elvie Electric Breast Pump Review. The Elvie electric breast pumps are also a hospital-grade pump and they stand out in this category with its innovative designs. Unlike traditional breast pumps, Elvie is wearable and fits discreetly inside your bra, offering convenience for busy parents. Elvie offers ultra-quiet pumps and is designed for ease of cleaning with fewer parts than other pumps. This combination of portability, discretion, and user-friendliness makes the Elvie an excellent choice for modern parents seeking an efficient and hassle-free breastfeeding journey. The Elvie Pump is available as a single wearable breast pump that comes with an app, or as a double wearable set, which includes an app. In this review, I’ll explore their features, performance, and overall value to help you decide if Elvie is worth purchasing.
Product Information
| Brand: | Elvie |
| ltem: | Single Wearable Electric Breast Pump with an app |
| Material: | Silicone |
| Color: | White |
| Product Dimensions: | 1.97″L x 0.39″W x 3.94″ 9 |
| Item weight: | 225 grams / 0.500 pounds |
| Batteries: | Built-in rechargeable batteries |
| Operation Mode: | Electric |
| Special Features: | Portable & hands free |
| Is it Dishwasher Safe?: | All pump parts are dishwasher safe. |
| Best Place to Buy: | Buy on Amazon |
Elvie Double Electric Breast Pump
Product Information
| Brand: | Elvie |
| Item: | Double Wearable Breast Pump with an app |
| Material: | Silicone |
| Color: | White |
| Product Dimensions: | 2.68″L x 2.68″W x 5.04″H |
| Item Weight: | 2 kg / 4.5 pounds |
| Batteries: | Built-in rechargeable batteries |
| Operation Mode: | Electric |
| Special Features: | Portable & hands free |
| Is it Dishwasher Safe:? | All pump components are dishwasher safe |
| Best Place to Buy: | Buy on Amazon |
Elvie Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Hands free: It fits in a standard nursing bra. The Elvie Electric Breast Pumps don’t have cords or need to be plugged in for use.
- Smartphone application integration: The device comes with an app that allows you to control the suction, pause the pump, monitor the volume, and track pumping history.
- Easy to clean: One of the advantages that many users have reported is that these electric breast pumps are easy to clean. The parts can be washed by hand or they can go in the dishwasher (top rack)
- Portable and compact: The pump is small and lightweight, making it convenient to take out with you.
- Quiet: The Elvie pump is known to be very quiet, which allows parents to use the device discreetly in public.
- Rechargeable: The pump is rechargeable via a micro-USB, and the battery lasts for approximately 5 and a half hours.
Cons:
- Incorrect volume estimates reported: Several users have reported that the app inaccurately estimates the volume of milk that has been pumped.
- Issues with leaking: Some moms have reported that the Elvie pump may leak if you bend over or move too much while using the device.
- Suction power concerns: Many users have noted that the suction power of the Elvie Breast Pump does not match that of other models on the market. However, it is reported that the Elvie Stride offers more effective suction compared to the Elvie Breast Pump.
- Price consideration: The Elvie breast pumps are priced higher compared to other electric pumps on the market.
Elvie Stride Electric Breast Pump Review
Best Wearable Electric Breast Pump
Welcome to the Elvie Stride Electric Breast Pump Review. This Breast Pump is also a hospital-grade pump, similar to the other Elvie breast pumps however, the primary distinction between them is that the original Elvie Pump is wireless, while the Elvie Stride includes tubing that connects the pumps to the cups.
The Elvie Stride Breast Pump transforms the breastfeeding experience with its sleek design and innovative features. Designed for modern mothers on the go. The pump’s intuitive controls and customizable settings cater to individual preferences, ensuring a comfortable and efficient pumping experience. Elvie Stride creates suction up to -300 mmHG in a single cup set up, with both stimulation and expression modes, plus 10 intensity settings per mode. These settings can be changed on the hub. Its compact size and rechargeable battery make it perfect for travel or use at home. The Elvie Stride Breast Pump empowers mothers to maintain their breastfeeding journey with ease and confidence.
Product Information
| Brand: | Elvie |
| ltem: | Stride Electric Breast Pump |
| Material: | Silicone |
| Color: | White |
| Product Dimensions: | 2.28 x 5.04 x 8.76 inches |
| Item Weight: | 225 grams / 7.9 ounces |
| Operation Mode: | Electric |
| Special Features: | Hands Free & Portable |
| Is it Dishwasher Safe? | The pump parts are dishwasher safe. |
| Best Place to Buy: | Buy on Amazon |
Elvie Stride Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Portable and compact: Like the other Elvie Breast pumps, it is small and lightweight.
- Suction: Several moms have reported that the suction is better than the other Elvie breast pumps.
- Smartphone application integration: The device comes with an app that allows you to control the suction, pause the pump, monitor the volume, and track pumping history.
- Rechargeable: The pump is rechargeable.
- Easy to use: Moms have mentioned that Elvie Stride is easy to use.
Last Thoughts!
When deciding between the Elvie Stride and the Elvie Breast Pump, there are several factors to consider. Firstly, the Elvie Stride’s suction is often reported to be more effective, typically collecting more milk. However, the Elvie Breast Pump has a smaller design and lacks external tubes or cords, making it more compact. It’s important to note that the Elvie Stride, with its external motor, is not as quiet as the Elvie Breast Pump. Additionally, the Elvie Stride is more affordable than the Elvie Breast Pump.
Although these products are pricier than some of the other brands, Elvie is a company well-known for its high-quality offerings. The pump features great usability, is easy to clean, portable, and most importantly, effective at expressing breast milk. If it fits your budget, I’d say it’s a worthwhile investment.
Momcozy All-in-One M5 Wearable Electric Breast Pump Review
Best Lightweight Breast Pump
Welcome to the Momcozy All-in-One M5 Electric Breast Pump Review. This hands-free pump mimics a baby’s mouth with its precise 105° flange slope pumping angle, ensuring painless pumping and encouraging letdown. The M5 breast pump features three different massage points to help alleviate clogged milk ducts. It includes a double-sealed flange and an ergonomic 105° breast wrap design for complete comfort. Portable and lightweight, it offers six intensity levels for each mode. Designed for convenience, it allows users to continue their daily activities while pumping. Additionally, the pump comes in four different sizes (17/19/21/24 mm) to accommodate various breast shapes and sizes.
Product Information
| Brand: | Momcozy |
| Item: | All-in-One M5 Electric Breast Pump |
| Material: | Silicone & Plastic |
| Color: | White & gray/mint/cozy red/lilac |
| Product Dimensions: | 2 x 3 x 4 inches |
| Item Weight: | 240 grams |
| Operation Mode: | Electric |
| Special Features: | Portable, Double Pump, Hands Free Usage, Wearable |
| Is It Dishwasher safe? | No, it is recommended to wash the parts in warm soapy water. |
| Best Place to Buy: | Buy on Amazon |
Momcozy Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Compact design & travel bag: The pump’s compact design and travel bag make it convenient to take to work or when out and about.
- Quiet operation: This pump operates quietly.
- Strong suction: Many moms have found that they can pump more milk than with other brands.
- Easy to clean: Moms love how easy it is to clean the Momcozy M5 pump. It is recommend that you use warm soapy water to wash the pumps components.
Cons:
- Not as discreet: The pump is not as discreet as some might prefer.
- Leaking: Moms have noticed that you have to be careful with movement while pumping, as too much movement can cause loss of suction and leakage.
Final Verdict!
The Spectra S1 Plus Premier Double Electric Breast Pump is our top choice overall, while the S2 is also a good purchase. For those who prioritize discretion, the Elvie Electric Single and Double Wearable Breast Pumps offer a sleek and quiet solution with app connectivity. The Elvie Stride Breast Pump stands out as the best wearable option, combining convenience with functionality. If a lightweight design without compromising performance is your priority, the Momcozy All-in-One M5 Double Wearable Breast Pump is an ideal pick. Each of these breast pumps offers unique advantages, ensuring a perfect fit for every mother’s needs.
Thank you for reading the review on Electric Breast Pumps I hope that it helped you decide which electric breast pump will be best for you.
Tarryn Liddell